Friday, December 12, 2008

A short commentary from Russ

Gift Giving During the Holiday Season
Gift giving during the holiday season is a tradition. It brings out the best in every one of us. For a short few weeks every year, all of our resources, time, and thoughts can go into making another person’s day by finding them the perfect little gift. We don’t even have to feel guilty about going in debt that will take months to pay off to do this. It is a back stage pass to the stage show of irresponsibility hidden by an opening act of charity and kindness. It is a show that when participated in cognitively can be the greatest show on Earth. But when practiced with reckless abandon it can become the worst thing we have ever done.
With that said, I ask the question. Why do we give gifts? Are we doing it to make someone else happy and content with life or are we doing it for our own selfish, anti-altruistic appetites in mind? Do we think about the effects, both negative and positive, of our choices in gift giving? Or do we only think that a positive act leads to a positive outcome? After watching television these last few weeks, I think we probably do more harm then good in our gift giving decisions. I think a part of our motives are in the right place, but our ignorance of the big picture cripples people rather than building them up.
As most of you have noticed, many of the big industries in the world have been asking for financial help over the last few weeks. Wall Street, specifically many of the banks, and now, most recently, the auto industry, have been looking for tens of billions of dollars of non-existent funds (we are trillions of dollars in debt as a nation already) for a “bail out” plan. These companies are those same companies whose executives own private planes, vacation homes, large 401K, incredible pension plans, and benefit packages that are worth more then the average persons’ income. In short, these industries are looking for large financial gifts amid fiscal irresponsibility.
What strikes me as most poignant is that these industries ask for money with no indifference to their own pride. Their hands are open asking for handouts while their bellies are full with crumbs on their lips. It is a conditioned response from the many years of governmental “gift-giving” with no accountability for what the money is going towards. Correct me if I’m wrong, but the last time I lost all my money in Vegas, went out and got a “gift” from a bank, then jumped back on a plane to Vegas, people said I had a problem. The bank didn’t help me “gifting” me the money. It enabled me to hurt myself ten fold in the long run. (it never actually happened, by the way)
One of the best examples of having good intentions but creating bigger problems is in the act of teachers giving students grades that they don’t deserve. I, myself, have been at fault for this on many occasions. Stories of being close to a “4.0”, or how some act of God befell them and they really deserve a better grade. Justification comes in that “they’re a nice kid” or that “their parents are good people and it hurts them more.” Most of the time, though, it deals with the student who is almost passing (if not for those 4 assignments they never turned in and that test they never came in to make up) and just needs that extra little bump at the end so that they pass the class. I think this is the worst possible gift a teacher can give to a student. It sends the non verbal message that passing is nothing more then a gift from a teacher and not a function of hard work. When we do this, we think we are giving students a leg up. Instead, we are taking their legs out from under them.
As this holiday season approaches, I think we need to have a serious conversation with ourselves, specifically with our motives of gift giving. We need to ask ourselves, “Why am I giving this gift?” “Is this hurting or helping?” “Am I causing a larger problem then the one I am trying to fix?” The unfortunate outcome of this is that some people might view the fix of this problem as doing less gift giving. I don’t think this is the case. In fact, I think that when we give more thoughtful gifts, we actually do more giving – both of time and monetarily. In the case of teaching, we should try to give gifts that will benefit students in the long run – thinking skills, responsibility, dependability, individuality, and intelligence. When we give out ‘bail-outs” we are not only not teaching those desired traits above, but we are actually taking students in the opposite direction of where they need to get to. We are creating a more dismal future filled with the same types of people that right now lead our many failing industries.

2 comments:

Danny's Mom said...

WOW!!! I am in a unique position as a student and adult. I can understand why students want a break. Specifically last semester I missed an "A" in my class by 1 question on my final test and she didn't give me the "A". Ouch. But, I think you are right that carelessness can cause a lot of damage. Justin and I have done our fair share of giving/enabling" and it has casued us to think more carefully in the gifts we have given. I'd like to think we are smarter now than a few years ago and that we won't make the same mistakes again. I think it is human nature to want to help others but you are right, we need to think about the consequences of our actions. Rachel

Gretch said...

"It is a back stage pass to the stage show of irresponsibility hidden by an opening act of charity and kindness." Dude, where did you learn to write like this...awesome. Very poetic and a total dadism. Interesting take on the bailout. We'll have to talk later about that.